Melissa is so condescending.  What purpose did it serve to ask if it was classic or cliche at that moment?  It was too late for him to change anything about it.  It was purely to embarass him in front of the other chefs.  I can maybe understand the warning while he was still cooking (although it usually just makes them screw up because they get nervous) or critiquing as to why a contestant was being eliminated.  But to do it as you’re serving up your dish in front of 10 other chefs is just humiliating.  It’s not the first time she done it.  She is so classless.